Thursday, December 13, 2012

Benghazi, Ansar al-Sharia, democracy supporters, confusion, and pathetic John McCain

To get some idea of the complexity of discovering what happened in the attack on the US diplomatic mission in Benghazi, read the Reuters' September 22, 2012, article, published after the jump.

It is thought that a militia, Ansar al-Shariah, headquartered in Benghazi, may have been responsible for the attack.  Benghazi citizens, angry at the attack on the US mission, stormed the two (or five) compounds of the militia and ran the militia membeers out of town.  Other militias were also attacked, including one pro-democracy one.

John McCain, who is lusting after the chairmanship of a special Benghazi committee (which will not be created) lest he fall irretrievably into a well-deserved obscurity, would have Americans untangle this mess.  Only one crazed by a lust for the public stage would make such a fuss.

A small illustration of the complexity:  A doctor in a hospital where Ansar al-Sharia had been providing security for the past six weeks is reported to have said the group had prevented anarchy. “I don’t know about their religion or ideology, but they solved problems,“ said Abdulmonin Salim. “I don’t care if they come from another planet. I want a secure hospital."

Ansar al-Sharia is one of many islamist brigades in Libya .  It opposes democracy as being contrary to Islamic principles.  Islamists in Turkey Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan and other pro-democracy nations in which Islam is he principal religion, disagree.  Most Libyans support democracy and strongly and violently disagree.

Here are some images of the US investigating team and of Ansar al-Sharia:


If more need be aid about the difficulty of forensic discovery, here is a team of US investigators at work in Benghazi.




Demonstrators chanted "No more al Qaeda!" as they entered the Ansar al-Sharia compound on Friday night


Ansar al-Sharia brigade members guarding the hospital in Benghazi.





The city of Benghazi, as shown in Google:


 Lahaina, Maui, Hawaii, trnsported to Benghazi






 And, of course, football, eveerywhere in the world:



London Free Press, Toronto, Canada

Libyan Islamist militia swept out of Benghazi bases
Peter Graff and Suleiman Al-Khalidi, 
REUTERS
Saturday, September 22, 2012 6:12:01 EDT PM
Members of the Libyan army walk towards one of the headquarters of the Islamist Ansar al-Sharia militia group to try to break into it after some protesters got shot at while trying to storm it in Benghazi September 22, 2012. REUTERS/Asmaa Waguih


BENGHAZI, Libya - An Islamist militia was driven out of the city of Benghazi early on Saturday in a surge of anger against the armed groups that control large parts of Libya more than a year after the overthrow of Moammar Gadhafi.
A spokesman for Ansar al-Sharia, which some U.S. and Libyan officials blame for the attack on the U.S. consulate in Benghazi last week in which the U.S. ambassador and three other Americans were killed, said it had evacuated its bases “to preserve security in the city”.
In a dramatic sign of Libya’s fragility, after sweeping through Ansar’s bases the crowd went on to attack a pro-government militia, believing them to be Islamists, triggering an armed response in which at least 11 people were killed and more than 60 wounded.
The invasion of Ansar al-Sharia’s compounds, which met little resistance, appeared to be part of a sweep of militia bases by police, troops and activists following a large demonstration against militia units in Benghazi on Friday.
The two main Islamist militias in Derna, a city in eastern Libya known as an Islamist stronghold, withdrew from their five military bases and announced they were disbanding, residents said on Saturday.
“Abu Slim had three camps and Ansar al-Sharia had two. So it’s five. Empty. All empty,” Siraj Shennib, a 29-year-old linguistics professor who has been part of protests against the militia, said by telephone.
Demonstrators in Benghazi pulled down militia flags and set a vehicle on fire inside what was once the base of Gadhafi’s security forces.
Hundreds of men waving swords and even a meat cleaver chanted “Libya, Libya”, “No more al-Qaida!” and “The blood we shed for freedom shall not go in vain!”
“After what happened at the American consulate, the people of Benghazi had enough of the extremists,” demonstrator Hassan Ahmed said. “They did not give allegiance to the army. So the people broke in and they fled.
“This place is like the Bastille. This is where Gadhafi controlled Libya from, and then Ansar al-Sharia took it over. This is a turning point for the people of Benghazi.“
Adusalam al-Tarhouni, a government worker who arrived with the first wave of protesters, said several pickup trucks with Ansar fighters had initially confronted the protesters and opened fire. Two protesters were shot in the leg, he said.
“After that they got into their trucks and drove away,“ he said. Protesters had freed four prisoners found inside.
PRESSURE ON OBAMA
Libya’s government had promised Washington it would find the perpetrators of what appeared to be a well-planned attack on the U.S. consulate, which coincided with protests against an anti-Islam video and the anniversary of the 9/11 attacks.
The attack and the outrage directed at the United States over the video across the Muslim world raised questions about President Barack Obama’s handling of the so-called Arab Spring.
Although Ansar al-Sharia denies any role in the consulate attack, the latest events in the cradle of Libya’s revolution appeared at least in part to vindicate Obama’s faith in Libya’s nascent democracy.
“It’s a pretty clear sign from the Libyan people that they’re not going to trade the tyranny of a dictator for the tyranny of the mob,“ said White House spokesman Josh Earnest.
Libyan political scientist Ahmad al-Atrash told Reuters: “People in Benghazi and all over Libya want to get these militias under control ... The overwhelming feeling is against any element that keeps the situation unstable.“
The second half of Friday night’s protest proved his point.
Continuing to chant anti-Ansar slogans, the crowd, swelling into the thousands, moved on to attack a separate compound where the powerful pro-government Rafallah al-Sahati militia, safeguarding a big weapons store, opened fire on the assailants.
As looters later tried to leave the scene, vigilantes wielding clubs and machetes tried to prevent them driving off with heavy weapons.
Officials at three hospitals told a Reuters correspondent they had a total of five dead and more than 60 wounded from the night’s violence.
Police found six more dead bodies near the compound on Saturday morning, police officer Ahmed Ali Agouri said.
The six dead men were bodyguards of a colonel in the regular Libyan army who went missing on Friday, and the prospect that the killings and kidnapping may have been the work of a militia group suggested there could be more tension between the army and militia in coming days.
“We came as peaceful protesters. When we got there they started shooting at us,“ student Sanad al-Barani said. “Five people were wounded beside me. They used 14.5 mm machineguns.“
Nasser Abdelhaaq, a Rafallah al-Sahati commander, said the brigade had returned to their compound on Saturday morning.
He suggested that the crowd had been deliberately manipulated to turn on Rafallah al-Sahati, an officially approved militia that also has Islamist leanings.
RELIANT ON MILITIAS
“Twenty-five percent of those who came were there as saboteurs,“ he said. “Some of them, we know who they are, they were working with Gadhafi’s security brigades.“
While the compound was being looted, the government texted Benghazi mobile phones asking citizens to go home and “not allow saboteurs to destroy your noble and successful demonstration“.
Libya’s new rulers know that, while militias pose the biggest threat to their authority, the state’s weak security forces rely on former rebel units, armed with heavy weapons, that fought in the uprising.
Like the rest of Libya, Benghazi is still prowled by dozens of armed groups operating openly, usually with the official permission of a government that is powerless to stop them.
Ansar al-Sharia’s overt Benghazi presence was never huge. But it was one of the few groups operating openly without official licence.
Its leaders proclaim democratic government to be incompatible with Islam, and the presence on the streets of pickup trucks bearing their Kalashnikov logo was an affront to the government’s authority.
But a doctor in hospital where Ansar al-Sharia had been providing security for the past six weeks said the group had prevented anarchy.
“I don’t know about their religion or ideology, but they solved problems,“ said Abdulmonin Salim. “I don’t care if they come from another planet. I want a secure hospital.“
Ansar al-Sharia and other Islamist militias have bases elsewhere in eastern Libya, notably around the coastal city of Derna, known across the region as a major recruitment centre for fighters who joined the wars in Iraq, Afghanistan and Syria.
The attack on the U.S. consulate seems to have provided a strong impetus for local authorities to rally support behind the weak national government.
Thousands of Libyans marched in Friday’s “Rescue Benghazi Day“ in support of democracy and against Islamist militias.
“It’s obvious that this protest is against the militias. All of them should join the army or security forces as individuals, not as groups,“ student Ahmed Sanallah said. “Without that, there will be no prosperity and no success for the new Libya.“
U.S. Ambassador Christopher Stevens was well liked, and many Libyans condemned the attack on the consulate despite being angered by the anti-Islamic U.S.-made film that triggered it.

No comments: